Here’s a detailed broker comparison between TradeNation vs SpreadEx across 11 different core broker criteria.
TradeNation vs SpreadEx Comparison
Swipe right on mobile to see broker comparisons.
| TradeNation VS SpreadEx | 
First | 
Second | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Regulation | FCA, ASIC | FCA | |
| Number of Instruments | 33 (Forex, Indices, Commodities) | 1000+ (Forex, Indices, Shares, Commodities, Sports Betting) | |
| MT4 | |||
| MT5 | |||
| cTrader | |||
| Proprietary Platform | |||
| TradingView Integration | |||
| Commission (Forex) | None | None | |
| Spreads | From 0.6 pips | Variable Spreads | |
| Free VPS Access | |||
| Islamic Accounts | |||
| Customer Service | 24/5, multilingual | 24/5, multilingual | |
| Education | Extensive | Moderate | |
| Copy Trading | |||
| Deposit Requirements | £100 | None | |
| Join TradeNation | Join SpreadEx |
Broker Comparison Criteria Breakdown
1. Trading Instruments
Winner: SpreadEx (for broader instrument variety).
TradeNation: Offers a range of markets, including forex, indices, and commodities. The platform focuses mainly on spread betting and CFDs but lacks the depth of instruments offered by other brokers.
SpreadEx: Offers a diverse range of financial instruments, including forex, commodities, indices, shares, and cryptocurrencies. Additionally, SpreadEx provides both spread betting and CFDs, and a unique option for sports betting.
2. Account Types
Winner: TradeNation (offers fixed spreads with no commission)
TradeNation: Offers a standard account designed for traders who want simplicity in both spread betting and CFDs. The platform supports traders in over 100 countries but lacks specialized accounts like Islamic accounts.
SpreadEx: Primarily offers standard accounts for both spread betting and CFDs but doesn’t provide different account types or demo accounts for practice. There’s no clear support for specific account structures, like raw spread or Islamic accounts.
3. Spreads and Commissions
Winner: TradeNation (offers fixed spreads with no commission)
TradeNation: Known for its fixed spreads, offering simplicity and cost predictability. There are no commissions on trades, which makes it attractive for beginner and intermediate traders.
SpreadEx: Uses variable spreads that are competitive but wider than other brokers for some markets. There are no commissions, but traders might notice larger spreads, particularly during volatile periods.
4. Platforms
Winner: SpreadEx (more flexibility with spread betting and proprietary platform)
SpreadEx: Provides its proprietary trading platform, primarily for spread betting and CFDs. It’s easy to use but lacks the advanced trading features offered by global trading platforms.
EightCap: Supports MetaTrader 4 (MT4), MetaTrader 5 (MT5), and TradingView, which are industry-standard platforms that offer advanced charting, automation, and custom indicators.
5. Automated Trading and Copy Trading
Winner: Neither (both lack extensive automation features)
TradeNation: Does not support automated trading or copy trading features. The platform is designed for manual trading only.
SpreadEx: Similarly, SpreadEx does not support automated trading features like Expert Advisors (EAs) or copy trading. The platform focuses on manual trading, primarily for UK users.
6. Execution Speed
Winner: Draw (similar market-maker models)
SpreadEx: Works as a market maker, meaning there might be slightly slower execution compared to ECN brokers.
EightCap: Provides an ECN-like environment with fast execution speeds, thanks to its no-dealing-desk approach, which helps minimize slippage and re-quotes.
7. Educational Resources
Winner: TradeNation (better educational support)
TradeNation: Offers an excellent range of educational resources, including webinars, tutorials, and market analysis. This makes it an excellent choice for beginners.
SpreadEx: Provides some educational content, but it’s not as comprehensive as TradeNation. It focuses more on the fundamentals of spread betting but could improve for advanced traders.
8. Customer Support
Winner: Draw (both offer similar customer service).
TradeNation: Offers 24/5 customer support via phone, email, and live chat, with a strong reputation for responsiveness.
SpreadEx: Similarly, SpreadEx offers 24/5 customer service, with a focus on UK-based traders. Support is available via phone, live chat, and email, and it receives positive feedback for customer care.
9. Deposit and Withdrawal
Winner: SpreadEx (for flexibility and no minimum deposit)
TradeNation: Requires a minimum deposit of £100 and offers standard methods like bank transfers and credit cards, with no deposit or withdrawal fees.
SpreadEx: Has no minimum deposit requirement, making it ideal for new traders or those wanting to test the waters with smaller sums. However, there is a £1 charge on deposits below £50, but withdrawals remain free.
10. Regulation
Winner: Draw (both have robust regulation).
TradeNation: Regulated by the FCA in the UK and ASIC, ensuring compliance with strict financial standards and security protocols.
SpreadEx: Also regulated by the FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) in the UK, ensuring robust security measures and compliance with top-tier regulatory standards.
11. VPS Access and Automated Trading
Winner: Neither (both lack VPS access)
TradeNation: Does not offer VPS access for automated trading. The platform is primarily manual, focusing on simplicity.
SpreadEx: Lacks VPS support, making it less ideal for traders looking to run automated strategies 24/7.
Verdict: Which is Better SpreadEx or TradeNation?
Whilst they are both two of the best spread betting brokers for beginners, TradeNation is the better option for beginner traders who value fixed spreads, no commission, and easy-to-use platforms with solid educational resources. The platform is designed for simplicity, with good customer support, and is ideal for traders who want predictability and transparency in their costs.
SpreadEx, on the other hand, shines for UK-based traders interested in both financial and sports spread betting. Its proprietary platform, no minimum deposit, and focus on spread betting make it a strong contender for those in the UK market, though it lacks some of the features & advantage of fixed spreads that TradeNation provides.
James is a former FTSE100 AI Director and trader with 10+ years trading his own capital. He is the Managing Director of SpreadBet.AI and currently trades his own capital through both CFD trading & spread betting as well as working with one of the leading prop firms in the world.
